Best Pet Insurance Providers of 2023

Compare America's Best Pet Insurance Services

List updated May 2024
39,571 Real Customer Reviews
Read Our Advertising Disclosure for More Details.

Pet Insurance Companies in Ohio

List updated May 2024
1
Consumers Top Pick
A+ Best Rating
9.8

Better Penny score

Pets Best
Personalized Plans for Your Cat or Dog
  • 90% Coverage Available
  • Fast & Effective claims
  • Zero Lifetime Limits
  • Zero Annual Limits
VISIT SITE
4547 Reviews
Trustpilot
4.0 of 5.0
TrustPilot Score

Based on 4547 User Reviews

High
Consumer Interest

Based on the past 7 days

Excellent
Products and Services

Better Penny Review Score

4547 Reviews
Trustpilot
2
9.4

Better Penny score

Spot
Pet Insurance You Will Both Love
  • 24/7 Vet Helpline
  • Includes Preventative Coverage
  • Covers Up to 90% of Costs
  • Microchip Coverage
VISIT SITE
4821 Reviews
Trustpilot
4.7 of 5.0
TrustPilot Score

Based on 4821 User Reviews

High
Consumer Interest

Based on the past 7 days

Excellent
Products and Services

Better Penny Review Score

4821 Reviews
Trustpilot
3
9.3

Better Penny score

Lemonade
Affordable Coverage for All Your Pet needs
  • Low Monthly Pricing Plans
  • Discounts Available
  • Fast Mobile App
  • Easy Claims Process
VISIT SITE
1915 Reviews
Trustpilot
4.4 of 5.0
TrustPilot Score

Based on 1915 User Reviews

Good
Consumer Interest

Based on the past 7 days

Great
Products and Services

Better Penny Review Score

1915 Reviews
Trustpilot
4
8.6

Better Penny score

Walmart
Use Any Vet and Get 90% Reimbursement
  • Discounts When Paying Annually
  • Accepted By All Vets
  • Simple Plans
  • No Sign Up Fees
VISIT SITE
9873 Reviews
Trustpilot
1.5 of 5.0
TrustPilot Score

Based on 9873 User Reviews

Good
Consumer Interest

Based on the past 7 days

Great
Products and Services

Better Penny Review Score

9873 Reviews
Trustpilot
5
8.5

Better Penny score

ASPCA
Complete Coverage For All Your Pets
  • Complete Coverage
  • Multiple Pet Discounts
  • Unlimited Coverage Plans
  • In Business Since 1997
VISIT SITE
5666 Reviews
Trustpilot
4.1 of 5.0
TrustPilot Score

Based on 5666 User Reviews

Average
Consumer Interest

Based on the past 7 days

Good
Products and Services

Better Penny Review Score

5666 Reviews
Trustpilot
6
8.5

Better Penny score

pumpkin
Voted “Best for Comprehensive Coverage” by Business Insider (2020)
  • Plans Cover Behavioral Issues
  • 10% Discounts for Additional Pets
  • No Breed or Upper Age Limits
  • 90% Reimbursement Rate for All Plans
VISIT SITE
1028 Reviews
Trustpilot
4.6 of 5.0
TrustPilot Score

Based on 1028 User Reviews

Average
Consumer Interest

Based on the past 7 days

Good
Products and Services

Better Penny Review Score

1028 Reviews
Trustpilot
7
8.1

Better Penny score

Embrace
Pet Insurance Designed by Real Pet Parents
  • Diminishing Deductible
  • Up to 90% Back
  • Coverage for Exam Fees
  • 24/7 Pet Health Line
VISIT SITE
3826 Reviews
Trustpilot
4.1 of 5.0
TrustPilot Score

Based on 3826 User Reviews

Average
Consumer Interest

Based on the past 7 days

Good
Products and Services

Better Penny Review Score

3826 Reviews
Trustpilot
8
7.8

Better Penny score

pawp
Get Unlimited Pet Care For Just $24/month
  • Text or Video Chat with Vets
  • Support Available 24/7
  • Get $3000/YR for 1 Vet Bill
  • Covers Up To 6 Pets
VISIT SITE
821 Reviews
Trustpilot
3.2 of 5.0
TrustPilot Score

Based on 821 User Reviews

Average
Consumer Interest

Based on the past 7 days

Good
Products and Services

Better Penny Review Score

821 Reviews
Trustpilot
9
7.4

Better Penny score

healthypaws
Pet Insurance With No Maximum Limits
  • Average Claim Process Of 2 Days
  • More Than 500k Pets Enrolled
  • No Caps On Claims Payouts
  • No Costly Add-Ons
VISIT SITE
60 Reviews
Trustpilot
4.3 of 5.0
TrustPilot Score

Based on 60 User Reviews

Average
Consumer Interest

Based on the past 7 days

Good
Products and Services

Better Penny Review Score

60 Reviews
Trustpilot
10
7.0

Better Penny score

trupanion
Trusted By Over 600,000 Pet Owners
  • Price Options For Your Budget
  • Decades of Experience
  • Offers Direct Payments
  • Breed Specific Coverage
VISIT SITE
7014 Reviews
Trustpilot
4.2 of 5.0
TrustPilot Score

Based on 7014 User Reviews

Average
Consumer Interest

Based on the past 7 days

Good
Products and Services

Better Penny Review Score

7014 Reviews
Trustpilot
Featured
Fast & Easy Claims Process!
Start Now

BetterPenny.com Score:

Our Ranking consists of the following 3 scoring criteria:

  • Total Score

    Total Score is a numerical estimate of the brand's overall quality based on reviews by anybody seeking to share a review. The brand's review score will be included in the our Total Score. If a company does not have a review rating, the total score will be determined solely by Consumer Interest.

  • Consumer Interest

    Consumer Interest is a simple calculation to determine how visitors engage with the brands on our website. User interest is based on clicks and transactions received in the last 7 days. This interest may vary based on an updated weekly average.

  • Products & Services

    Our editorial staff researches and reviews financial services based on criteria such as product and service range, ease-of-use, online accessibility, customer support, special accolades, and more. Each brand is assigned a score for each criterion based on the offerings in that category. If our staff is unable to discover information relevant to a brand's Products & Services Score, it will not be calculated.

Consumer Reviews

Pets Best
Read review
Lemonade
Read review
ASPCA
Read review
Pumpkin
Read review

Recent Reviews

For weeks I researched through all the different insurances for animals and found Spot to be the very best overall, pricing, coverage even reimbursement time. I wanted an Ins I knew I could rely on an I’m happy to say Spot really came through!! There was an unfortunate situation with my 6month old pup, she had ingested something toxic, rushed her to the E.R animal hospital, Drs ran several tests gave different treatments an kept her overnight. Luckily my pup was ok and cleared to come home, which was the most important thing in the end but the bill was expensive. ($1,416) I opened the App, uploaded the invoice an in 3 days I had $1,050 returned to my account (90%) this also included my deductible ($250) so now for the rest of this year I won’t have to pay that again and would be reimbursed even more if god forbid something else happens. Everything was very easy and fast! Spot really was the Right choice! Thank you Spot for all the help!!

LDOhio reviewed Healthypaws

My too smart for his own good dog opened a mason jar and ate a bunch of chocolate. At the emergency clinic you could tell the vet wanted to keep him overnight but was worried the expense would be too much. I said I have pet insurance and her whole body relaxed. My doggo got the best care, has no liver damage and is back to his old self. I received a reimbursement check within a week and can now pay off my credit card with zero interest. So thankful for Healthy Paws

Linda reviewed Pumpkin

Pumpkin Ins. is awesome. We have had nothing but positive experiences. Our Frenchie had spinal surgery last year and our Boston had rectal surgery this year. Pumpkin has supported us all the way. Vet bills are horrible these days. So if you have pets whether it be dogs or cats you need Pumpkin. I don’t know what we would do without it. Thank you Pumpkin.

Josh D reviewed Embrace

My partner and I are INCREDIBLY grateful for Embrace Pet Insurance. We insured our three cats about a year or two ago when we adopted our two youngest ones. I was pretty skeptical about pet insurance. If it was anything like my regular health insurance for myself, I expected they'd never come through when I needed them. But I was willing to give them a shot. Well, turns out the oldest one ended up developing Feline Lower Urinary Tract Disease and was rushed to the vet, hospitalized for three days, and had to undergo surgery to save his life. When you're in the moment, you'd do anything for your little one. And at first glance of the bill, my heart sank. We had just started getting our savings up and this would have tanked us. But then I remembered that we pay for Embrace every month. And boy am I grateful we do! We had the majority of our costs reimbursed! And I'm even happier to report that our little guy is happy and healthy again! I'm grateful for Embrace because they are truly a great thing to have in your back pocket.

Steve S reviewed Pumpkin

Easy and fast

Our #1 Consumer Choice
A+ Best Rating
9.8

Better Penny score

Pets Best
Personalized Plans for Your Cat or Dog
  • 90% Coverage Available
  • Fast & Effective claims
  • Zero Lifetime Limits
  • Zero Annual Limits
4.0
TrustPilot Score

Based on 4547 User Reviews

High
Consumer Interest

Based on the past 7 days

Excellent
Products and Services

Better Penny Review Score

What is Pet Insurance?

Pet Insurance is pet health insurance that covers the pet you love with monthly or yearly premiums. The idea of pet insurance is to provide coverage for unexpected expenses like veterinary care, emergency treatments and prescriptions.

Benefits of Pet Insurance

Pet insurance can help reimburse pet owners for an expensive emergency vet bill or even cover costs associated with certain pre-existing pet conditions.

  • Helps you save money.
  • Opens new treatment possibilities for you.
  • Allows you to concentrate on your pet's health.
  • Gives you the freedom to pick your plan.
  • Keeps you from using your savings.
  • Helps budget the cost of pet care.
  • Gives you peace of mind.
  • Pick your own vet.



Do I Need Pet Insurance?

According to most pet owners, pet insurance is well worth the investment. To begin with, there are several advantages to having pet insurance, and you may need pet insurance if:

  • You like to take your pet with you on vacation.
  • You like to try out new pet products and services.
  • Your pet requires prescription pet foods.
  • You like to spoil your pet with new pet toys and products frequently.
  • Your pet has a history of expensive pet medications or pet conditions.
  • You want to be able to choose your veterinarian without worrying about vet costs.

The average veterinarian bill is $200 - $400 for dogs and $90 - $200 for cats. Surgeries and unexpected procedures can cost over $5000, and all that money is 100% out of pocket if you do not have pet insurance.



Types of Pet Insurance

There are two types of pet insurance: comprehensive and accident-only. For an extra charge, you may purchase additional health, dental, and other types of coverage.

The most common pet accidents include:

  • Foreign Object Ingestion 
  • Struck by a Car
  • Dog Bites
  • Poisoning
  • Cat Bite Abscesses
  • Eye Injuries
  • ACL and MCL injuries
  • Dehydration



Optional Coverage

Wellness Coverage
This covers basic pet costs, checkups, vaccinations, and spay/neuter.

Dental Coverage
This pays the cost of pet dental cleanings and extractions.

Hearing Coverage
This pet insurance covers the cost of hearing tests, ear infections, ear mite treatment and surgery.

Flea, Tick, & Heartworm Coverage
This pet insurance covers the cost of blood tests, preventative treatment, and surgery.



How Much Does It Cost?

Accidents and Illnesses

  • Dogs approximately $50 a month
  • Cats approximately $28 a month

Accident Only

  • Dogs approximately $18 a month
  • Cats approximately $11 a month

The cost of pet insurance is determined by your dog's breed, species, and age, as well as your coverage deductible, reimbursement percentage, and annual limits. The pet insurance provider may also consider your pet's veterinary history, age, and breed when determining pet insurance premiums.



What Does It Cover?

Most pet insurance policies cover accidents, illnesses, and surgeries. The specifics of what pet insurance covers vary by policy, so it is important to read the terms and conditions carefully before purchasing pet insurance. Most pet insurers also offer additional coverage for things like prescription medications, dental care, and behavioral therapy.

What is Not Covered?

Pet insurance does not typically cover preexisting conditions, routine care, or pet wellness visits. Therefore, it is important to read the terms and conditions of a pet insurance policy carefully before purchasing coverage.

Interesting Facts

  • About 68% of households own a pet.
  • The first year of owning a dog costs roughly $1,200.
  • The lifetime cost of owning a cat can be up to $20,000.
  • The lifetime cost of owning a cat can be up to $7,000.
  • The first year of owning a cat costs roughly $1,100.
  • Only 1.7% of all pets have insurance.
  • Adopt a dog or cat from a shelter.



Conclusion

When it comes to pet insurance, there are multiple companies to choose from. How do you know which one is the best for your pet? By use Better Penny, of course! Better Penny pet insurance reviews can help you get a better idea of what each company offers and how they stack up against the competition. Better Penny can also help you find discounts and deals that may not be on the company’s website. And finally, Better Penny can give you peace of mind knowing that you are making the right decision for your pet.